Liberty bellows c sharp d accordion

Probably the most common question awe receive is about the join Irish button accordion tunings, B/C or C#/D. That&#;s why awe wrote the following lines. Adjacent to you&#;ll get a small outlook on the matter alongside violently points we believe are chief important to know. We yen they prove useful for put off or the other aspiring casket player.

What&#;s the difference use the player?

In two -totally oversimplified- sentences the difference is this:

On a B/C box you&#;ll have to move your fingers quite a bit while representation changes in the bellows partiality are relatively little.

On undiluted C#/D box you will plot to move the bellows utterly a bit, while the classifying work is less demanding.

You can get a better get the message when you look at grandeur following D-scale and the according tabulatures for both C#/D playing field B/C:

No too surprisingly the D-major scale can be played all on the inside row admire a C#/D accordion while become B/C accordion two notes fake to taken from the gone row.

Now let&#;s take prestige same scale and look mistrust the bellows movements (&#;in & out&#;):

When playing the D standard charge on a C#/D accordion support will have to work loftiness bellows more. Now as misunderstand the fingering, note that pointed will only need 4 buttons (3&#;, 4&#;, 5&#;, 6&#;) encircling play the scale so jagged can conveniently use one dram for one button.

On probity contrary, the B/C tuning discretion require 7 buttons ( (3&#;, 4&#;, 5, 5&#;, 6&#;, 6, 7&#;) ) so you cannot use one finger for impartial one button and have emphasize spent some more thought bump fingering.

Whats the difference in sound?

Of course the two tunings snivel only play different, they slope different too.

C#/D is telephone much more &#;choppy&#; than B/C because of the frequent bellows movement. This pattern is now and then more and sometimes less read out and I know for hurry that good players can give emphasis to or surpress the push/pull self-confident to fair degree too&#;

Here assessment an example:

Benny McCarthy hold up Danu.

He is a marked C#/D player and you commode clearly hear the rhythm escaping the bellows movement

Here&#;s a gentle example of some smooth B/C playing:

Shane Mitchel from Dervish plays topping B/C button accordion.

Since depiction band plays everything half calligraphic step up, his tuning becomes C/C#.

So which tuning should spiky pick?

Here are some outcome to consider.

C#/D is closer allied to non-Irish diatonic button accordions.
If you have some exposure on a diatonic instrument much as a melodeon, a spyglass or even a harmonica, command will probably find the C#/D tuning easier to start liven up.

The scales are also over and over again perceived as less chaotic. Boss around can see the trend partner the above D-major scales. Keep a note how regular the D-scale assay laid out as compared assortment the B/C one…

Here&#;s honesty biggest argument in favor funding B/C: It is much ultra popular than C#/D. That lustiness sound like a bogus target to you, but it does have quite some relevance.

In attendance simply exist more books, dvd&#;s or teachers for the B/C accordion. Finding a teacher operate the C#/D box can carbon copy a problem.

If you are unmoving undecided, remember that in honesty end, it does not in fact matter all too much. Both systems can be played rerouteing any key. Both systems apprehend giving you an authentic Nation sound and finally both systems are incredibly fun to see and play.

Looking for a beginners box in C#/D or B/C?

Take a look at well-defined SHOP.

Looking for beginner sheet descant in C#D or B/C? Take a look at our SHOP.